欢迎来到星沙英语网

状语从句是修饰主句还是主句中的动词

来源:www.jdzsu.com 2025-05-22

[1]It began to rain when I was watering the garden.

[2]It was very wise to leave when you did.

[3]I will leave when you do.

这三句,根据张满胜老师的说法,[2]中的when修饰leave, 而不是修饰主句,该句可以改写为To leave when youdid was very wise.

[1]则修饰主句,可以改写为When I was watering the garden, it began to rain.

对于这两种改写我都没疑问。

问题是,修饰主句这一说法的模糊性。若是修饰某一动词,以时间状语为例,还可以说明该动词发生的时间。

[问题]

1.那样修饰主句的意思是呢?表示"主句所代表的事件"发生的时间吗?主句所代表的事件发生了,也肯定涉及动词,所以时间状语最后还是落到动词发生的时间了。所以两种说法有什么区别只不过修饰什么动词吗?修饰主句的限定动词就是修饰主句吗?

2.第一句可否说修饰"began to rain"呢,状语从句表示开始下雨的时间。

3.第三句,张满胜老师的意思是修饰leave。我感觉[3]的意思是When you leave, Iwill leave to.这么说修饰主句也可以吧?

我感觉区别一个状语是谓体状语还是句子状语,只须是主句为否定句时,状语是不是在否定范围之内。假如时间状语是句子状语,则否定范围不包括状语,该状语放在句末和句首,一般意义不变。以下是夸克对时间状语的简短说明:

8.51  

... ...

Time adjuncts are readily predicational when a verb lacks other complementation :

The guests arrived in the early evening.

I waited till14.30.

She is coming this afternoon.

But when there is alternative complementation, most types of time adjunct

just as readily assume a sentential function:

I waited patiently enough for an interview till 4.30.

Till 14.30, I waited patiently enough for an interview.

She is coming for a tutorial this afternoon.

In many cases, moving a sentential adjunct from E to I has no effect on

interpreting the scope of negation:

She isn't coming for a tutorial this afternoon.

This afternoon, she isn't coming for a tutorial.

We didn't speak to each other during the entire afternoon.

During the entire afternoon, we didn't speak to each other. 

相关文章推荐

09

11

certainly修饰对象的剖析

Because of interest, the money you should pay back certainly exceeds the original debt.请问,certainly在句子中是修饰pay back? 还是修饰

06

04

怎么样剖析修饰语的修饰对象(涉及as从句)(3)

The alchemy of time also helps, transmuting bad rebels into negotiating partners, as the years have done to Northern Ire

06

03

怎么样剖析修饰语的修饰对象?(8)

Prosperity seemed so uniform and inevitable that country wives in Taegu and Chengdu got rice cookers—gaining all the mor

09

25

作定语还是状语(过去分词修饰对象辨析)

Here and there a fire, forgotten in the last rush, lingered and in a sudden excess of strength fed upon the dry bones of

英语学习 热门搜索

更多>